Dr. Val Farmer
Rural Mental Health & Family Relationships

Confronting A One-Sided Marriage

June 20, 2011

What can you do with a man, devoted to his work and family, who is so right, rigid and judgmental that every conversation has the potential for an argument?

However well-meaning he might be, what comes across is a steady barrage of interruptions, rebuttals, and criticism. He is a poor listener. Years of poor listening lead to a self-centered view of life. A relationship can be nit-picked to death. Everywhere there are mountains, no molehills.

A woman commented, "Oh, how I wish my husband would just relax and quit telling me how to do everything - even things that donft matter - like how to hang my towel on the rack so it will dry faster, how to arrange the things in the refrigerator so theyfll be easier to reach, and how to fold the newspapers before putting them in the waste container." She doesnft like it.

Or perhaps a self-centered perspective on life makes for poor listening. The lack of understanding, respect, and ability to empathize take a continuous toll on his marriage.

Perfectionism, rigidity or selfishness? Or maybe it isnft so much about being right but being selfish. Itfs not poor communication that takes a toll but the lack of it. A man can get carried away in his own pursuits, agenda and having things go his way that he ignores his wifefs needs and her perspective. He just skips the argument part and does what he pleases anyway.

Whether it is perfectionism, rigidity, or just plain selfishness, the need to be right and/or to be in control causes a wife to feel loneliness, emotional isolation and feelings of being unloved, unappreciated and disrespected.

Women married to men like this come to see their husbands as unemotional, self-sufficient, proud, domineering, inconsiderate, unforgiving, impatient, and seldom pleased. As husbands, they come across as more concerned about being right or getting their way than how their partner feels. They:

- don't have a clue that their generously given 'common sense' and advice is so hurtful.

- don't realize how little regard they have for their spouses' thoughts and feelings and how separate and independent they have become when making decisions.

How does a man like that see himself? Probably as strong-willed, determined, independent, productive, decisive, and confident. His biggest problem in life is why his wife ignores his priorities and concerns.

Steps a woman can take. What is the answer for relationships like these? What does it take to break through this escalating cycle of arguments and emotional withdrawal? Since a man like this probably doesnft see himself as the problem, or may not feel like there is much of a problem anyway, his wife may have to provide the corrective changes.

She can:

- find an outside source of help through a friend, minister, counselor, or relative. She needs to be strong - strong enough to confront her husband and make it stick. She has to be different enough that when she confronts him with ultimatums or consequences she is believable. Going for counseling on her own may be a needed step in this process.

- gain power by finding other sources of self-esteem and worth such as with a job, friendships, and hobbies that provide satisfaction independent of the marriage. By making herself happy and independent, she sets the stage for correcting the flaws in the relationship.

- confront her husband and insist on counseling. By going, half the battle is already won. The husband places himself in a dependent situation where he does not set the rules. This is a level playing field where the power between them is equalized. Counseling is a place where he will be held accountable for his promises, words, and actions.

Understandably, the counselor has to be strong enough to deal with powerful personalities and emotions. A combination of gentleness and strength are necessary to hold this man in therapy and to confront painful issues caused by his own actions.

If the stakes are high enough and his motives strong, he will work at changing. Counseling is strong medicine, but it is preferable to separation or divorce.

Benefits of counseling. The habit of not listening is so strong that it takes the presence of a counselor to demonstrate the skills, to observe, make helpful suggestions and correct mistakes. Listening for understanding is difficult for someone who is used to filtering everything through his own strong emotions and opinions.

By learning to listen, he will hear and understand his wifefs emotional pain. Itfs not just words, itfs also body language. It is teaching someone the basics of empathy - to understand and respect anotherfs plight and to respond emotionally to it. He will learn to give love instead of expecting it as a right.

Communication skills by themselves may not be enough. Connections need to be made between domineering and controlling behavior and childhood family experiences. This style of relating was probably present in his own family where his father or mother was an imposing and tyrannical figure. The lack of warmth and concern he projects corresponds to the lack of warmth and concern he once felt as a child.